top of page

Exploring Traditional vs Electric Pressure Canners: Making an Informed Choice

As a home cook and avid preserver, I've used traditional and electric pressure

pressure canner gauge
Pressure canner vs Electric pressure canner

canners. Each method comes with its own set of benefits and considerations, and in this blog post, I'll provide an impartial overview of the two options. Whether you're a seasoned canner or just beginning your preserving journey, understanding the pros and cons of each approach will help you make an informed choice.

Traditional Pressure Canners: A Tried-and-True Method

Traditional pressure canners have been the go-to choice for many home canners for decades. These stovetop models are often made of heavy-duty aluminum or stainless steel and require careful monitoring throughout the canning process. Here are some of the advantages and considerations associated with traditional pressure canners:


1. Versatility: Traditional pressure canners can handle a wide range of canning tasks, including high-acid and low-acid foods. They are ideal for canning meats, vegetables, soups, and more.

2. Durability: Traditional pressure canners are built from sturdy materials to withstand frequent use, making them a long-lasting investment.

3. Capacity: Traditional canners often come in larger sizes, allowing you to process larger batches of food, which can be convenient for preserving bountiful harvests.


1. Manual Monitoring: One of the main drawbacks of traditional pressure canners is the need for constant attention. The pressure and temperature must be closely monitored, and adjustments need to be made throughout the canning process.

2. Learning Curve: Mastering the art of using a traditional pressure canner may take some practice. It requires a solid understanding of pressure and temperature management to ensure safe and successful canning.

3. Time and Energy: Using a traditional pressure canner can be more time-consuming as it has longer heating up and cooling down periods, in addition to the actual canning process. Moreover, the energy required for stovetop canning may be higher compared to electric models.

Electric Pressure Canners: Convenience at Your Fingertips

In recent years, electric pressure canners have gained popularity among home canners. These all-in-one units combine pressure canning functionality with automated features, making them a convenient choice for those seeking efficiency and ease. Here's an overview of the advantages and considerations of electric pressure canners:


1. Set-and-Forget: Electric pressure canners offer a hands-off approach to canning. Once you set the desired settings, the unit takes care of maintaining the pressure and temperature, allowing you to focus on other tasks.

2. Precise Control: Electric models often come with pre-programmed settings for various canning tasks, ensuring consistent results. Some units even have sensors to monitor and adjust the temperature automatically.

3. Energy Efficiency: Electric pressure canners are known to be more energy-efficient than traditional models. They tend to have better insulation and regulate heat more effectively, which can lead to reduced energy consumption.


1. Limited Capacity: Most electric pressure canners have smaller capacities compared to traditional models. The limited capacity may be a consideration if you often process large batches of food or have a bountiful harvest to preserve.

2. Learning the Controls: Electric pressure canners come with various settings and features, which may require some time to understand and master. Familiarizing yourself with the unit's functionality is crucial for safe and successful canning.

3. Reliance on Electricity: Unlike traditional pressure canners, electric models require a power source to operate. This reliance on electricity means that you may face challenges during power outages or if you prefer to can outdoors without a power supply.

Choosing Your Perfect Canning Companion

When it comes to deciding between traditional and electric pressure canners, the choice ultimately depends on your personal preferences and needs. Traditional pressure canners offer versatility and durability but require more attention and monitoring. On the other hand, electric pressure canners provide convenience and precise control but come with limited capacity and a learning curve.

For me, the transition to an electric pressure canner made sense as it required less attention and suited the needs of my smaller household. However, I must emphasize that both traditional and electric pressure canners are excellent options for home canning enthusiasts.

So, whether you prefer the tried-and-true approach of traditional pressure canners or the convenience of their electric counterparts, both methods will enable you to preserve and enjoy the delightful flavors of your favorite foods throughout the year. Happy canning!

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this blog post are my personal opinions and experiences. Always follow the manufacturer's instructions and guidelines when using pressure canners to ensure safety during the canning process. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Your purchase through one of the links helps me offset the costs associated with this website. Learn more!

119 views0 comments


bottom of page